Macro Update - 6 April 2020

Falling uncertainty – good for recovery from the virus, bad for the economy

Steven Bell

Managing Director, Portfolio Manager & Chief Economist, Multi Asset Solutions


Falling uncertainty – good for recovery from the virus, bad for the economy. Steven Bell explains why, and also argues why he believes interest rates will stay low despite the huge stimulus measures.


Uncertainty about the virus has fallen in a good way as we know more about the profile of its spread, as the growth of new cases and fatalities in Italy and Spain follow the same patterns as in China and South Korea. The US is at an earlier stage, although the daily rate of deaths has slowed in New York, the worst-hit state. The liberal democracies of Europe and the US still need more time to emulate the containment successes seen in Asia; if not, the authorities will face very difficult decisions about when to relax their respective lockdowns.

Uncertainty has also fallen regarding the economic damage from the pandemic, but not in a good way. Forecasters have finally realised just how horrendous the economic damage is going to be. Last week, I highlighted that over 4 million Americans filed for unemployment. A number totally without precedent – until the end of last week that is, when another 6 and a half million followed suit. Economic growth looks set to drop by at least 10% in both Europe and the US for the current quarter. Another record.


Central banks go large, but interest rates may not

Central banks around the world have flooded the markets with liquidity and unconventional measures have become the norm as governments have announced huge fiscal packages. Japan is the latest to join the list. Government deficits will exceed 10% of the respective economies in most countries; perhaps closer to 20% for the US. We expect the Euro-group to announce a big package this week. Many fear that, as a result of all this, interest rates will rise and global austerity programmes will need to be put in place once the world has recovered from the virus. I’m not so sure. It is true that government debt will be much higher and interest rates may be a bit higher, but the forces that kept rates low before the pandemic will still be there, if anything, stronger.


Economic recovery is still an unknown

 Fiscal and monetary policy can soften the blow of this massive recession but only an end to the lockdown will produce economic recovery. The evidence from China is promising, production has recovered to 80-90% of previous levels. Consumers have been slower to recover, partly because they have had to draw down their savings, but they are coming back. For the rest of the world, it all depends on stopping the spread of the virus, not merely containing it. Some experts, including the ones advising the UK government, expect the lockdown to be eased and tightened in phases over a period of up to a year. If that’s the case, recovery will be relatively slow compared to the sudden stop caused by the imposition of the lockdown. The honest answer is that we just don’t know. But even on pessimistic assessments, we should see a vigorous economic recovery over the latter part of this year and into 2021.


What does this all mean for markets?

Dividends are being slashed, earnings are collapsing, defaults will rise. But markets are forward looking, and if they feel confident that this will prove to be temporary – and I think they will – they will trend higher. The S&P 500 has been in a relatively narrower trading range since the US passed their bumper fiscal package. Markets may well require signs that the lockdowns in Europe are set to be eased, and there will be setbacks, but I still think we’re headed higher.

Risk Disclaimer

The value of investments and any income derived from them can go down as well as up and investors may not get back the original amount invested.

The information, opinions, estimates or forecasts contained in this document were obtained from sources reasonably believed to be reliable and are subject to change at any time.

Subscribe to our Insights

Related articles

No posts matching your criteria

ESG Viewpoint – COVID-19 and the pharmaceutical industry

How is the pharmaceutical industry responding to COVID-19?

Investor engagement: Case studies

Discover three investor engagement case studies

ESG Viewpoint: COVID-19 and labour-related impacts

Labour issues are likely the biggest corporate theme resulting from the pandemic, with the impact on workers not being felt evenly. Discover the issues workers have been facing and learn about our engagement on social practices.

The ESG implications of COVID-19: Focus on ocean health

Our ocean ecosystem is in crisis owing to the negative effects of human activity. Discover how this problem is being exacerbated by COVID-19 and the resultant rise of single-use plastic.

The ESG implications of COVID-19: Focus on food production

Here we explore the food-related challenges of the COVID-19 crisis, and the role for investor engagement.

COVID-19 and climate change

Energy-related CO2 emissions are set to fall 8% in 2020 to their lowest level in a decade. But this just a short-term effect of the temporary lockdowns that won’t bend the curve longer term. Explore the impact of the pandemic on the fight against climate change and our related engagement.

ESG implications of the COVID-19 pandemic

We consider the implications of the COVID-19 pandemic on ESG issues.

Market update – 24 March 2020

Paul Niven – F&C Investment Trust fund manager – offers an update on market events.

Market update – 18 March 2020

Paul Niven – F&C Investment Trust fund manager – offers an update on market events.

Gender Diversity – a decade of progress, but it must continue

Gender diversity is progressing but we recognise there is still much more to be done to ensure organisations are diverse at all levels, beyond just the boardroom. Discover our engagement here from 2018-2019, as well as our voting plans ahead.